LAISHA
Open Laisha

Burning straw is not free

Short · · 48 s

Burning residue loses most of its nitrogen and sulphur and kills soil life. Chop and spread straw at harvest and sow through it with a zero-till seeder; aim for at least 30 % cover. The full video covers what burning costs, sowing through stubble, conservation agriculture, measuring residue cover, straw as fertiliser and the real problems with their fixes.

Tillage: primary, secondary, conservation and zero tillage →

Subscribe on YouTube

What burning takes from the field

Crop residues are a store of nutrients and carbon. When straw is burnt, almost all of its nitrogen and much of its sulphur are lost to the air as gases, along with most of the carbon. Some phosphorus and potassium remain in the ash, but ash blows and washes away easily. A tonne of rice straw holds roughly 5 to 8 kilograms of nitrogen, about 1 kilogram of phosphorus, 12 to 17 kilograms of potassium and around 1 kilogram of sulphur, so a field with 6 to 8 tonnes of straw loses a useful amount of fertiliser value every time it is burnt.

Heat at the surface also kills soil organisms and destroys the organic matter that binds soil into crumbs. Over years, repeated burning leaves soil harder, poorer at holding water and more prone to crusting.

The cost beyond the farm

Smoke from residue burning carries fine particles (PM2.5), carbon monoxide and other pollutants over whole regions. In north-west India, post-monsoon rice straw burning is a major contributor to winter smog episodes. Burning also releases greenhouse gases such as methane and nitrous oxide and black carbon. Many governments now restrict or ban open burning of crop residues.

What to do instead

The practical alternative is to keep the straw on the field and sow through it. A combine fitted with a straw management system chops and spreads straw evenly. Machines such as the Happy Seeder or Super Seeder can sow wheat directly into rice stubble, leaving the straw as a surface mulch that conserves moisture, smothers weeds and moderates soil temperature. Straw can also be incorporated with a rotavator or mould-board plough where time allows, or baled for fodder, mushroom substrate, bioenergy or compost.

Even distribution is the key to success. Heaped straw blocks seeders and creates patches where the next crop emerges poorly.

How to measure residue cover

Conservation agriculture aims for at least 30 per cent of the soil surface covered by residue after sowing, the figure used to define conservation tillage. The line-transect method measures it simply: stretch a 15-metre tape or rope diagonally across the rows, look straight down at 100 evenly spaced points, and count how many points sit on a piece of residue large enough to protect the soil. The count is the percentage cover. Repeat in a few places and average.

Sources: Singh Y, Sidhu HS, Management of cereal crop residues for sustainable rice-wheat production in the Indo-Gangetic plains, Proceedings of the Indian National Science Academy 80 (2014) · USDA NRCS, Estimating crop residue cover (line-transect method) · FAO, Conservation Agriculture

Transcript

Burning your straw to clear the field fast? It is not as free as it looks.

Burning residue loses most of its nitrogen and sulphur, and much of its carbon, and it kills the soil organisms that keep your soil open and alive.

The smoke fills the air for whole regions.

Instead, chop and spread the straw at harvest, and sow straight through it with a zero-till seeder. The straw stays on top as mulch. Aim for at least thirty per cent of the soil covered after sowing. You can check it by counting one hundred points along a fifteen-metre line.

The full guide to managing crop residue without fire is in our long video and at laisha.ai.

Last updated · How Laisha writes and checks its pages · Report a mistake

Ask Laisha about this

Opens Laisha's chat with your question ready to send. Sign in or start free.

Go further with Laisha Smarter

US$10 a month · one price worldwide · cancel any time

  • Ask Laisha about what you watched — up to 1,000 questions a month
  • Your own crop calendar and pest alerts
  • Every calculator and tool
10 days free for every new account, no card.