LAISHA
Open Laisha

Is your compost too wet or too dry? The 1-second squeeze test

Short · · 40 s

Squeeze a handful from the middle of the heap: a few drops means just right; water running means too wet (turn it and add browns); no water means too dry (water it as you turn). The full video covers the mix, the hot phase and fixing a smelly heap.

Organic farming: principles, standards and certification →

Subscribe on YouTube

Why moisture decides how compost behaves

Composting is done by microbes, and microbes live in the thin film of water around each particle. Too little water and they go dormant: the heap stays cool and dry material barely changes for months. Too much water fills the pore spaces, oxygen cannot get in, and anaerobic microbes take over. They work slowly and produce sour, rotten-egg or ammonia smells, and nitrogen is lost as gas.

The ideal moisture for most composting is about 50 to 60 per cent by weight. Because few farms weigh samples, the squeeze test is the practical check: it feels like a wrung-out sponge.

How to do the test properly

Take material from inside the heap, at least 30 centimetres in, because the surface dries out and the base can be wet. Squeeze a handful as hard as you can. One or two drops between the fingers means the moisture is right. Water running out or dripping steadily means it is too wet. If nothing appears and the material crumbles apart when you open your hand, it is too dry.

Repeat in three or four places, because heaps are rarely even, and check again a few days after each turning.

Fixing a wet or dry heap

A wet heap needs air and dry carbon. Turn it to open it up, and mix in dry, carbon-rich material such as chopped straw, dry leaves, sawdust or shredded cardboard. Cover the heap during heavy rain, and build it on a slightly raised, well-drained base. If the smell is ammonia rather than sour, there is also too much nitrogen-rich material (fresh manure, green leaves, kitchen waste) relative to carbon.

A dry heap needs water added gradually as you turn it, layer by layer, so that it soaks in rather than running off the outside. In hot, dry climates, a cover of straw, sacking or a tarp reduces evaporation.

Getting the heap hot

Moisture is one of four things that make a heap heat up; the others are the carbon-to-nitrogen ratio (about 25-30 to 1 to start), particle size (small enough to pack but not so fine that air cannot move) and size of the heap (roughly at least one cubic metre so it holds heat). With all four right, the centre reaches 55 to 65 °C within a few days. Keeping it at 55 °C or more for several days, and turning so all material passes through the hot core, kills most weed seeds and pathogens. Compost is mature when it no longer heats after turning, smells earthy and the original materials are no longer recognisable.

Checking finished compost

Compost that is ready for use is dark, crumbly and moist but not sticky. Squeezed, it holds together loosely and breaks apart with a light touch. If finished compost is sour or slimy, spread it thinly to air for a week or two before using it near young plants, because the products of anaerobic decay can harm roots. Store finished compost covered, so rain does not leach its nutrients or waterlog it again.

Sources: Rynk R et al. (eds), The Composting Handbook (2022) · FAO, On-farm composting methods (Misra RV, Roy RN, Hiraoka H, 2003)

Transcript

Is your compost too wet or too dry? There is a one-second test.

Take a handful from the middle of the heap and squeeze it hard. If a few drops of water appear between your fingers, the moisture is just right, like a wrung-out sponge.

If water runs out, it is too wet. It will smell sour or rotten.

Turn it, and mix in dry straw or leaves.

If no water appears at all, it is too dry, and it will stay cold.

Water each layer as you turn it.

How to get the heap hot enough to kill weed seeds is in our long video, and at laisha.ai.

Last updated · How Laisha writes and checks its pages · Report a mistake

Ask Laisha about this

Opens Laisha's chat with your question ready to send. Sign in or start free.

Go further with Laisha Smarter

US$10 a month · one price worldwide · cancel any time

  • Ask Laisha about what you watched — up to 1,000 questions a month
  • Your own crop calendar and pest alerts
  • Every calculator and tool
10 days free for every new account, no card.