Plants need water, nutrients, oxygen at the roots and support, but not soil. This guide covers a short history of hydroponics, the main water systems (nutrient film technique, deep water culture, aeroponics, ebb and flow), substrate culture with drip fertigation (rockwool, cocopeat, perlite; open and closed systems), the nutrient solution and why it is kept in two stock tanks, EC and pH targets with solution temperature and oxygen, a worked calcium nitrate stock solution, the honest pros and cons (including water use and organic certification), and what to check when plants suddenly wilt.
Plants need water, nutrients, oxygen at their roots, and something to hold them up. But they do not strictly need soil.
Hydroponics means growing plants with their roots in a nutrient solution.
Soilless culture uses an inert substrate, such as rockwool or cocopeat, fed with the same kind of solution. Most greenhouse tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers, and many cut flowers in northern Europe, are now grown this way,
and so is a growing share of the world's lettuce and herbs.
In this video: the main systems, substrates, the nutrient solution and why it comes in two tanks, the two numbers that control it, EC and pH, a worked stock solution, the honest pros and cons,
and what to check when plants wilt. The advice is general and global.
Plant scientists grew plants in nutrient solutions in the nineteenth century, to work out which elements are essential.
In nineteen twenty-nine, W.
F. Gericke, at the University of California, grew tomatoes several metres tall in solution culture, and coined the word hydroponics.
In nineteen thirty-eight, Hoagland and Arnon published nutrient recipes that are still widely used. In the nineteen sixties and seventies, Allen Cooper in England developed the nutrient film technique. And rockwool slabs from Denmark became the standard greenhouse substrate.
In true hydroponics, the roots grow in the solution itself.
There are four main designs.
In the nutrient film technique, or NFT, a thin film of solution flows down slightly sloping channels, past the roots, and back to a tank. It uses little solution, but if the pump fails, plants can die within hours.
It is common for lettuce, herbs and strawberries.
In deep water culture, plants sit in rafts floating on a deep, aerated tank. The large volume of water buffers temperature and nutrients, so it is more forgiving.
It is common for lettuce and leafy greens.
In aeroponics, roots hang in the air and are misted with solution.
It is used in research, in vertical farms, and to produce seed potato minitubers.
And in ebb and flow, benches or trays are flooded and drained in turns.
It is used for pot plants and seedlings.
In all of them, roots need oxygen as well as water and nutrients.
In substrate culture, plants grow in a medium,
and a drip system feeds them the nutrient solution.
This is called drip fertigation, and it is how most greenhouse tomatoes,
cucumbers and peppers are grown.
Rockwool, or stone wool, is uniform and easy to manage, but difficult to dispose of. Cocopeat, made from coconut husks, is renewable and widely available in the tropics, but it must be washed first, to remove salts.
Perlite, vermiculite, expanded clay, sand, and bark or peat mixes are also used.
Substrate systems can be open, where the drain water runs to waste, or closed, where it is collected, disinfected, topped up and reused.
Closed systems save water and fertiliser and reduce pollution,
and some countries require them.
The nutrient solution must supply every essential nutrient, in balance.
Field fertilisers often lack micronutrients, or contain insoluble fillers, so hydroponics needs fully soluble, balanced fertilisers.
And they usually come in two concentrated stock tanks. Why two?
Because, when concentrated, calcium reacts with sulphates and phosphates and falls out of solution as a solid. So tank A holds calcium nitrate, potassium nitrate and iron chelate.
Tank B holds potassium phosphate, potassium sulphate, magnesium sulphate and the micronutrients. An injector dilutes both into the irrigation water, often at one part in a hundred. Never mix the two concentrates directly.
Two numbers control the solution.
The first is electrical conductivity, or EC, a measure of the total dissolved salts.
Typical targets are about one point five to three millisiemens per centimetre, depending on the crop and its stage. They are lower for lettuce and higher for tomatoes, where a higher EC improves fruit flavour, but reduces fruit size.
The second is pH.
Keep it at about five point five to six point five, where most nutrients stay available.
Larger systems dose acid or alkali automatically.
Two more things matter at the roots.
Keep the solution at about eighteen to twenty-four degrees Celsius,
and keep it oxygenated.
Warm, stagnant solution holds little oxygen,
and encourages root rots such as Pythium.
Let's make a stock solution.
A grower wants one hundred and fifty milligrams of nitrogen per litre in the final solution, from calcium nitrate, which contains fifteen point five per cent nitrogen and nineteen per cent calcium.
For one thousand litres of final solution, that is one hundred and fifty grams of nitrogen.
Divide by zero point one five five, and you need about nine hundred and sixty-eight grams of calcium nitrate. That also supplies about one hundred and eighty-four milligrams of calcium per litre.
Now the stock. With a one to one hundred injector, each litre of stock becomes one hundred litres of solution. So a one-hundred-litre stock tank supplies ten thousand litres, and needs nine point six eight kilograms of calcium nitrate, dissolved in tank A.
Other nitrogen sources, such as potassium nitrate, reduce how much calcium nitrate you need.
Growers balance all the salts with a recipe spreadsheet,
and then check the final EC.
The advantages are real.
High yields and quality, with precise control of nutrition.
Water efficiency: one often cited comparison found hydroponic greenhouse lettuce using roughly a tenth of the water of field lettuce, per kilogram. No soil-borne diseases, nematodes or weeds at the start.
And crops can grow where soils are poor, salty or absent: in deserts, on rooftops and in cities.
So are the disadvantages.
High capital cost, and dependence on electricity, pumps and monitoring. It takes skill in water chemistry. In recirculating systems, root diseases can spread fast through the shared water, so it must be disinfected, by UV, heat, filtration or chemicals.
Used substrates and drain water must be disposed of.
And not every crop pays: staples such as wheat and rice are grown far more cheaply in soil.
One more point for marketing.
Hydroponic produce can be certified organic in some countries, but not in others.
In the European Union, for example, organic production must be soil-based.
Hydroponics also runs the windowless vertical farms, where lettuce grows on stacked shelves under LED lights. They use very little water and, sealed off, usually no pesticides.
But the sun delivers light for free, and a vertical farm must buy it.
For lettuce, the lighting alone takes roughly thirteen kilowatt hours of electricity per kilogram. Add the air conditioning to remove that heat, plus pumps and fans, and published estimates of ten to twenty kilowatt hours or more per kilogram of leafy greens are common.
That is why vertical farms grow leafy greens and herbs, not staple crops.
And it is why, from about twenty twenty-two,
as energy prices rose, several high-profile vertical farming companies in Europe and North America closed or shrank. Those that do better sell premium, very fresh produce, raise seedlings, or work where field growing is very difficult.
For most growers, hydroponics will stay in greenhouses, which use sunlight.
What if your NFT lettuce suddenly wilts? The most common cause is a pump failure or a blocked channel. In NFT, roots dry out within hours, so check the flow first, and have an alarm or a backup.
The other usual culprit is root rot, from warm, poorly oxygenated solution.
If so, cool and aerate the solution.
And does hydroponic food taste worse? Not necessarily.
Flavour depends mainly on the variety, light, nutrition and ripeness at harvest.
Hydroponic tomatoes grown at the right EC and picked ripe can taste as good as soil-grown ones.
To recap.
Plants need water, nutrients, root oxygen and support, not soil.
Choose a system: NFT, deep water, aeroponics, ebb and flow, or substrate with drip. Use fully soluble fertilisers, in two stock tanks,
calcium apart from sulphates and phosphates. Hold EC at about one point five to three, and pH at about five point five to six point five. Keep the solution cool and full of oxygen.
And protect yourself against pump failure.
For more on growing every crop, visit laisha.ai. Thank you for watching.
Last updated · How Laisha writes and checks its pages · Report a mistake
US$10 a month · one price worldwide · cancel any time
An AI operating system for agriculture: free guides, manuals and tools written for every country.