Doubling the dose raises cost, residues and risk and usually speeds resistance up. First check dose, coverage and timing; then switch to an effective product from a different IRAC, FRAC or HRAC group. Changing brand within a group achieves nothing.
Raising the rate above the label only helps if the resistant insects, mites, fungi or weeds survive at the normal rate but die at the higher one. Many resistance mechanisms, such as an altered target site, protect a pest at ten or even a hundred times the field rate, so doubling it simply kills more of the remaining susceptible individuals and leaves the resistant ones with less competition. The opposite shortcut is no better: Australian experiments with rigid ryegrass showed that repeatedly spraying below the label rate selected for metabolic resistance within a few generations, so the label rate is the one to keep.
An off-label rate is also illegal in many countries, can injure the crop, raises residues above maximum residue limits, and increases the risk to the person spraying, to bees and to water.
Most so-called failures turn out to be application problems. Before suspecting resistance, check the sprayer: nozzle output within about 10 per cent of the chart, correct pressure and travel speed, and a measured litres-per-hectare figure. Water-sensitive paper clipped inside the canopy shows whether droplets reached the undersides of leaves where whiteflies, mites and aphids feed.
Then look at timing and conditions. Was the pest at a susceptible stage, such as young caterpillars or small weeds? Did rain fall within the rain-fast period? Was the spray water very alkaline, which breaks down some organophosphates and carbamates quickly? Was the product old or stored in heat? Did the weed escape because it was too big or under drought stress?
Signs pointing to resistance are a patch where the product failed while the same spray worked elsewhere, live pests of mixed sizes on treated plants after a good application, and a history of the same group used repeatedly in that field. For weeds, a mix of dead and healthy plants of one species, next to dead plants of other species, is a classic sign.
Send samples for testing. Many universities and public laboratories run bioassays for insects and weed seed, and fungicide sensitivity tests for diseases such as cereal mildews and grey mould. Your extension service or the national IRAC, FRAC or HRAC country group can advise where.
Switch to an effective product with a different mode-of-action group number, and treat that as the start of a planned rotation, not a one-off. Add non-chemical measures that pests cannot resist the same way: resistant varieties, crop rotation, removing crop residues, natural enemies, cultivation or hand weeding of survivors, and stopping resistant weeds from setting seed.
Record the field, product, group, rate, date and result of every application. A few seasons of notes show which groups still work on your farm and which are fading.
A new brand name is not a new tool if its group number matches the old one. Mixing two products from the same group adds nothing against resistance. A tank mix with a partner the pest already resists offers no protection to the other partner. And resting a group for a season rarely restores it fully, because resistance genes tend to persist in the population.
Your spray stopped working, so you double the dose?
Please do not.
A higher dose raises cost, residues and risk, and it usually speeds resistance up.
First check the basics: the dose, the coverage and the timing. A poor spray is not resistance.
If the pest really is resistant, switch to an effective product from a different mode-of-action group. Look for the IRAC, FRAC or HRAC group number on the label. Changing the brand within the same group achieves nothing.
The number to remember:
in a simple model where each spray kills ninety-five per cent of susceptible insects, resistance takes over in about three generations.
The full guide is in our long video and at laisha.ai.
Last updated · How Laisha writes and checks its pages · Report a mistake
US$10 a month · one price worldwide · cancel any time
An AI operating system for agriculture: free guides, manuals and tools written for every country.